Anyone else want to tell a story about ignorant lab TA's?
In the electronics 1 lab today, we're doing a lab with center tapped transformers and a half-wave rectifier. Mid way through the experiment we're supposed to replace the 10k load with a 100 ohm resistor to see how it reacts. Not thinking, I blindly do it and start to notice something smelling bad. Unplug everything and notice the resistor is getting hot... ok makes sense. Decrease the resistance by a factor of 100, your current is going to increase by a factor of 100. That much current through a 1/4 W resistor no good.
I point this out to the TA and he starts asking about what value of filter capacitor are we using. It doesn't matter, we're pushing too much current. He just doesn't get it. Next thing I know 3 people in the room have burned their fingers when the 100 ohm is too hot and the freaking TA can't seem to figure out why. How dumb can grad students be?
Joined: Fri 08-04-2006 9:39AM Posts: 1373 Location: Boston
Source: Fidelity
berto wrote:
LostBoyz wrote:
chill the fuck out, you are supposed to put that size resistor then figure out the other values, if i remember correctly
everyone in our class burned them, too. We were the last group to go, we knew what we were supposed to do, but still blew the resistor
The TA should still understand why it's happening and he doesn't. I believe that was his point.
unless the TA was trying to pull the "I'll act like I don't know what's going on even though I do" sort of meneuver so that they can learn the lesson themselves. I'm not saying it's likely, but it's possible. I mean, they don't really teach TAs how to teach so they just make their own stupid lesson mistakes.
_________________ "Jesus is never mad at us if we live with him in our hearts!"
"I hate to break it to you, but he is--he most definitely is."
The word "bi-partisan" usually means some larger-than-usual deception is being carried out.
Joined: Mon 09-06-2004 7:51PM Posts: 1916 Location: The B Barn
Source: Off Campus
I don't know what you are bitching about. That is what that class is. You will probably burn up some LEDs, BJTs and FETs before the end of the semester too. Checking the capacitor size does seem a little silly to me in this application. Anyways, your electronics TA sounds better than the person I had. Kosbar told us that he wanted to fire our TA, but he had to fire the other one first and he only had one possible person to be a replacement.
chill the fuck out, you are supposed to put that size resistor then figure out the other values, if i remember correctly
everyone in our class burned them, too. We were the last group to go, we knew what we were supposed to do, but still blew the resistor
What pissed me off is that he couldn't understand, even after I explained it to him, why the resistor was burning up. He either didn't understand the concept of ohms law or he doesn't know how to communicate with his students. Yes I agree that the purpose of the lab was to replace the resistor and calculate the value of the capacitor, but after we showed him that the resistors were burning up, he started asking what value of C we were using, in case somehow that was causing some huge increase in current.
When I have to write up a lab report, that he is going to grade, and I can't do the last part of the experiment because of laws of physics, he better damn well understand why that wasn't in the lab report.
Joined: Mon 09-06-2004 7:51PM Posts: 1916 Location: The B Barn
Source: ERL Building
Or you could put that in your lab report with a solid explanation on why it happened and the upper/lower limits for resisitive loads in your report. Or I suppose you could sensly bitch some more.
Or you could put that in your lab report with a solid explanation on why it happened and the upper/lower limits for resisitive loads in your report. Or I suppose you could sensly bitch some more.
Please don't take the high road like you haven't bitched about a class or classwork before. You're an idiot. Thanks for playing.
Joined: Mon 09-06-2004 7:51PM Posts: 1916 Location: The B Barn
Source: ERL Building
berto wrote:
FrankieM wrote:
Or you could put that in your lab report with a solid explanation on why it happened and the upper/lower limits for resisitive loads in your report. Or I suppose you could sensly bitch some more.
Please don't take the high road like you haven't bitched about a class or classwork before. You're an idiot. Thanks for playing.
Or you could put that in your lab report with a solid explanation on why it happened and the upper/lower limits for resisitive loads in your report. Or I suppose you could sensly bitch some more.
Please don't take the high road like you haven't bitched about a class or classwork before. You're an idiot. Thanks for playing.
See, I can do it too.
lololol
+1
_________________ I have now been banned twice. Do not mess with me. Also, you suck.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum