ok so im looking to get a new hdd for my media center.. ive been looking at the 300gb maxtor maxline 3 sata150... from some of the newegg reviews it seems like there is a perty high failure rate after little usage.. does any one have one of these, or know some one who does..

or would i be better off going with another brand.. im a fan of as is maxtor... and its 16mb catch... delicious

i've got a 300GB ata133 maxtor (w/16mb cache)... its been working great about 8 months so far. as for the sata version, i don't know